This morning the PG wants us to vote among five songs that will become the new 'anthem' for Pittsburgh. The idea seems to be to have one of these songs adopted in time for this summer's All-Star Game. Millions of people - all potential tourists - will have this song in their ears and on their lips creating a cascading crescendo of renewed pride in our town.
To frame this competition, the PG provided a list of popular city songs (what, no "Dirty Water???"). Unfortunately, there's not an "I Left My Heart in PNC Park" or "I'm in a Pittsburgh State of Mind" among the entries below. We listened to all five. Here are our thoughts:
"Pittsburgh" - the 30 second long intro, with a Sly Stone "Family Affair" groove, seems like it was done for one of those WTAE commercials where the smiling anchors are placed in various landmarks around town. Some lyric snippets: "Where you can catch a game on the shores of fame, and catch a night in a city so bright"... "You can go to the Strip and move your hips." "You've got a friend in PA and Pittsburgh too." Triple yoi.
"The Pride of Pittsburgh" - sounds like something the Convention & Visitors Bureau hired an ad agency to do. The very first line refers to the "City of Champions". The cliches pile up from there.
"This Place Where I Come From" - now we're getting somewhere. Interesting imagery of barges and rivers and industry. Small towns, valleys, farmlands... getting it done. It has sort of Mellencamp feel to it in both lyrical and musical construction. You couldn't see Tony Bennett singing it, but you could see Springsteen (or Joe Gruschecky) giving it a go.
"I Love Pittsburgh" - this is live recording by Jimmy Sapienza, opens by mentioning every other town's signature song, then immediately lists every Pittsburgh sports team. Is that what we're selling? Jimmy sings that "You can ride the subway" without mentioning you can only do so from the South Hills. Lyrics like "big time with a small town heart" will win some fans. There's a bit of a boozy lounge feel to the song and if it became popular, it would be a karaoke hit. "Look a pothole."
"Shot and a Beer Town" - if it were George Thorogood or Tom Waits performing this 15 years ago, it would've been a hit. This is a pretty good song. "In this shot and a beer town, people keep on toiling, the bridges shine just over the Kensington sky". It's the type of song you'd expect to hear on an album like "Nebraska". However, it's not the kind of happy, bouncy singalong tune that you'd use to promote a city. It's too introspective and thoughtful for that - and you'd want to listen to it with a shot and a beer.
Give a listen and vote for your favorite.
Recent Comments